TruHourly

Job Offer Comparison Calculator

Two offers are never just two numbers. The bigger salary can lose to state tax, and an hourly wage can beat a salary once overtime is counted. This calculator runs both offers through the same after-tax model — federal tax, FICA and each state's tax — and declares the winner in take-home pay. And unlike most comparison tools, it takes hourly offers as well as salaries, hours and overtime included, so you can compare the two kinds against each other.

Quick answer: with the offers prefilled below — $25 an hour in Texas against a $60,000 salary in California — the California salary wins in cash, by $4,694 a year after tax. Adjust for local prices, though, and the Texas offer goes further. Put your own two offers in and see which way yours falls.

Adds a row showing what each take-home is worth at national-average prices, using the BEA's state price levels (2024). Off by default — the headline verdict is always the money itself.

Job A

$

Hours are your total week; overtime hours are part of that week, paid at 1.5× (hourly offers only). For a salaried offer, enter the week you actually expect to work — it drives the per-hour row in the results.

$

Job B

$

Hours are your total week; overtime hours are part of that week, paid at 1.5× (hourly offers only). For a salaried offer, enter the week you actually expect to work — it drives the per-hour row in the results.

$

The verdict — after tax (2026 estimates)

Job B wins by $4,694 a year — that's $391.17 more a month after tax.

Before tax the gap between these offers is $8,000 a year; federal tax, state tax and FICA bring it to $4,694.

Measure Job A Job B Difference (B − A)
Gross pay (pay + bonus) $52,000 $60,000 +$8,000
Federal income tax $4,060 $5,020 +$960.00
State income tax $0.00 $1,734 +$1,734
FICA (Social Security + Medicare) $3,978 $4,590 +$612.00
Take-home per year $43,962 $48,656 +$4,694
Take-home per month $3,664 $4,055 +$391.17
Take-home per biweekly paycheck $1,691 $1,871 +$180.54
Take-home per hour worked $21.14 $23.39 +$2.26

Estimates only. Not tax or payroll advice. Both offers are run through the same simplified model as the take-home calculator — 2026 federal brackets after the standard deduction, FICA, and each state's effective rate — so the comparison is like for like.

Estimates only. Not tax or payroll advice.

What this comparison does not count

Health-insurance premiums, 401(k) contributions and employer match, the value of paid time off, and commuting costs are not in the table — and neither is the cost of living, unless you switch on the adjustment (which uses state-average BEA prices; a city can differ sharply from its state). When the take-home gap is small, these are often the real decision — see "Beyond the paycheck" below.

Worked example: $25 an hour in Texas vs $60,000 in California

The two offers prefilled in the calculator, single filer, 40 hours a week. Job B pays $8,000 more before tax — watch what the three tax layers do to that gap:

Single filer, 2026 estimate Job A — $25/hr, Texas Job B — $60,000, California
Gross pay $52,000 $60,000
Federal income tax $4,060 $5,020
State income tax $0.00 $1,734
FICA (Social Security + Medicare) $3,978 $4,590
Total tax $8,038 $11,344
Take-home pay per year $43,962 $48,656
Take-home per hour worked $21.14 $23.39

In cash, Job B wins — by $4,694 a year, or $391.17 a month. The state layer is the whole story of the narrowing: California takes $1,734 that Texas does not, and the higher gross also pays $960.00 more federal tax.

Adjust for prices and it flips. Texas prices average 2.9% below the national level and California's 10.7% above it (BEA, 2024). At national-average prices, Job A's take-home is worth $45,275 against Job B's $43,953 — the Texas offer goes further by $1,322 a year, despite paying $4,694 less in actual dollars. Neither answer is "the truth" on its own: the cash figure is what lands in your account, the adjusted figure is what it buys where you would actually live.

How to compare two job offers

The method this calculator follows — and the order to think in when the offers are your own:

  1. 1

    Annualise honestly

    Turn everything into a yearly gross on the same basis: hourly rate × hours × 52, with overtime at 1.5×; salary as stated; any bonus added to its offer. Comparing a wage to a salary without this step compares unlike things.

  2. 2

    Tax each offer where it is earned

    Federal tax follows the money; state tax follows the map. Run both offers through the same model — same filing status, same rules — or the comparison is rigged before it starts.

  3. 3

    Read the per-hour truth

    Divide take-home by the hours you will actually work. A larger salary built on a 50-hour week can pay less per hour than a smaller one on 40 — and the extra ten hours a week are yours, not the employer's.

  4. 4

    Then weigh what money can't show

    If the after-tax gap is a few hundred dollars a year, it is not the decision — benefits, time off, commute and stability are. Use the verdict to find out whether you are in that territory at all.

Beyond the paycheck

The calculator prices the paycheck honestly — but a job is not only a paycheck. Four things routinely outweigh a modest take-home gap, and none of them appear on an offer letter's headline number:

  • The 401(k) match is pay. An employer matching 4% of a $60,000 salary adds $2,400 a year that never reaches this calculator — enough, on its own, to erase a take-home gap of $2,400 between two offers. A generous match on the "losing" offer can quietly make it the winner; ask both employers for the match formula, not just whether one exists.

  • Health premiums come out before tax — and vary. The employee share of health insurance is deducted from gross pay, and the gap between two employers' plans can run to more per month than the entire tax difference above. Get the actual premium for the plan you would choose from both employers before treating a small net gap as decisive.

  • Paid time off is paid time not worked. Two offers at the same salary with three weeks of PTO versus one pay the same gross — but the first buys back two weeks of your year. This tool counts the hours you enter as worked, so extra PTO raises your real rate in a way the table understates; count the days as part of the offer.

  • Stability and the commute compound. A longer commute is an unpaid second shift — fuel, wear and hours, five days a week — and a job likely to last, with raises that build on this year's salary, outearns a slightly higher offer that ends in eight months. None of this is in the table, deliberately: it belongs in your decision, not in a formula pretending to price it.

Comparing job offers — questions, answered

Can a lower-paying offer be worth more after tax?

Yes — and it does not take an extreme case. A $28-an-hour job in Texas grosses $58,240 a year, which is $1,760 less than a $60,000 salary in California. After tax, the Texas job takes home $48,976 against the California salary's $48,656 — the "smaller" offer wins, because Texas takes no state income tax while California takes $1,734 of the $60,000, and the federal bill is lower on the lower gross. Gross pay is the number on the offer letter; net pay is the number you live on.

Why does the state change the winner?

Federal tax is identical wherever you work, so the state is the only tax layer that moves between two offers. State income tax runs from nothing in states like Texas, Florida and Washington to an effective $1,734 on a $60,000 salary in California under this model — and higher still in states like Hawaii and Oregon. That is easily enough to overturn a few thousand dollars of gross difference. Prices move the other way, too: the cost-of-living toggle adjusts each take-home by the BEA's state price level, which is why the demo offers swap places when it is switched on.

Should I compare job offers on gross or net pay?

Net — always. Tax is not a flat percentage: the higher offer pushes more income into higher federal brackets, and if it sits in a taxed state it pays a state layer the other offer may escape entirely. In the worked example above, an $8,000 gross gap between the two offers becomes $4,694 after tax — barely more than half survives. Comparing gross systematically flatters the higher-paying offer in the higher-tax state.

Does a signing or annual bonus change the picture?

It changes year one, and the bonus field above lets you see exactly by how much. A bonus is taxed as ordinary income — the same federal brackets, FICA and state tax as salary — so a $5,000 bonus does not put $5,000 in your pocket. Two cautions: a signing bonus is one-off, while the same money as salary repeats every year and compounds with percentage raises; and some signing bonuses must be repaid if you leave early. Compare the offers once with the bonus included (year one) and once without (every year after) before deciding.

What if one job is hourly and the other is salaried?

That is exactly what this calculator is built for — most comparison tools accept only annual salaries. The hourly offer is annualised at the hours you enter, with overtime at 1.5×. For the salaried offer, enter the hours you will actually work, not the hours in the contract: an $80,000 salary is $38.46 an hour on a 40-hour week but $30.77 an hour on the 50-hour week many salaried jobs quietly expect. The "take-home per hour worked" row is where that difference shows up.

Related calculators